All reviews

Dominican Republic / Mild-Medium

XO

Patoro

By Benjamin Charles Brown

A dusty-wrapper Dominican XO that opens musty and mild with savory red pepper, cinnamon, and cedar before a final third of cream, butter, and almond. Uneven burn and low smoke density suggest drier conditioning, but the late almond-butter character hints at real aging potential.

In the Cigar Database
80.0Captaincy Score
Published
July 15, 2026
Vitola
Extra Robusto, 5 x 58
Wrapper
Dominican (9-12 year aged)
Price
$28-$32 single
Binder
Dominican
Filler
Dominican
Patoro XO
Patoro XO mid-smoke with uneven burn line and flaky ash
Mid-smoke, showing the uneven burn and brittle ash.
Patoro XO lit at night with dusty wrapper and jagged burn
Burn still correcting after the wavy start.
Final nub of the Patoro XO with uneven burn and flaky ash
The final nub, where cream, butter, and almond finally arrive.

Tasting progression

First third

First lit draws were mild but a little musty, unsurprising given the dusty wrapper look. Once that faded, a smooth, mild, savory profile emerged with red pepper, cinnamon, and woody cedar. Very gentle spice on the retrohale. Earth and espresso began developing as intensity built gently. Burn line started very uneven but stabilized after correction.

Second third

Largely a continuation of the first third. Nothing particularly notable beyond a slight build in flavour intensity.

Final third

Became more interesting. Pepper largely faded with the introduction of creaminess, butter, and almond. Woodiness continued and the flavours integrated well. A delicious bready, fermented pungency emerged that would have been welcome throughout the whole cigar.

Final Verdict

An interesting smoke with potential given the right condition and ageing. No unpleasant flavours, and intensity never became excessive in the final third. In current condition there is nothing that makes it truly memorable or begs a repeat, which ought to be the case at this price point and level of aged leaf. If age can integrate the unique almond-butter taste of the final third into the whole cigar, it could become an incredible smoke.